At the recently concluded Munich Security Conference, American officials delivered a message that was both familiar and ominous: Europe must do more for its own defense. While this refrain has been heard before, this year’s conference had a different tenor.
The uncertainty surrounding America’s future commitment to NATO has never been higher, as senior officials hinted at growing impatience within Washington. If European allies continue to underinvest in their militaries and rely disproportionately on American security guarantees, they may soon find themselves without them.
French President Charles de Gaulle once remarked, “Treaties are like roses … They last while they last.” His skepticism about American dominance in European security remains relevant today. Likewise, Canadian Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau famously observed, “Living next to you [the U.S.] is in some ways like sleeping with an elephant … No matter how friendly and even-tempered is the beast, one is affected by every twitch and grunt.”
Both statements capture the lingering concerns among NATO allies, which include the reliability of American leadership; the extent to which Europe can, or must, stand on its own; and the implications for Canada and Europe of a world in which U.S. security guarantees can no longer be taken for granted.
Author
